This week at the Library of Congress Teaching with Primary Source Summer Institute was amazing. I got to meet and learn with and from 30 awesome educators from all over the country and would recommend attendance to anyone who wants to learn more about Primary Sources in the classroom. It was a jammed-pack week of learning that usually had my head overfilled with ideas as I set to personalize my learning to create a relevant project for my learning environment. Each day offered new opportunities and strategies that at times caused my thoughts on my project to veer. However, using the expectations, goals, objectives, strategies, routines and timelines really help me be a successful student with learning and thinking about the way students should be using personalized learning during the day at school. These are my reflections as a learner personalizing the learning from this institute for a project using Primary Sources with the students in my classes. This blog has deliberately been created "backwards" so that those following my blog were able to see the newest information at the top.
Day 5-Sharing, the end but not the end...
You probably noticed that the last topic on day 4 was sharing and how important I said it was but didn't really elaborate. Day 4 was long and day 5 of the institute was all about the sharing. A gallery walk was the sharing strategy of choice. This gallery walk was set up differently than I had experienced before. I felt that the design and set up was valuable to me as a presenter(teacher) and as the learner, I want to describe the design. Similar to a science fair there are tables where the teachers set up their projects and learners visit the different projects and are given time to listen to a short presentation and ask relevant questions. Constructive feedback from the learners could also be given to the teacher using a sticky note that each table had available. The teacher could even take notes from questions etc for revising their project later. The class was divided into 3 groups which rotated. each person when in their role as a learner had a starting place so that the learners were distributed among all the projects with a note sheet the learner used to take notes on the different projects. Each teacher had about 5-10 mins to set up and 15 mins to present to at least 3 sets of visitors during that time. This gallery walk work as the last feedback opportunity before submiting our final projects. I really liked this form of sharing. Unfortunately not all participants get to see all the projects, so if there was an opportunity for a final quick 2-3 minute TED talk whole class presentation would have been an ideal finish for our projects. Here is the link to my project After reviewing my project, please leave a comment with feedback. I believe a project is never finished it is only finished at this moment with more to come if there is time. This is a skill students need to be taught and learn.
Day 4-it is long, but truly a personalized learning journey
Day 4 began with building our understandings of the Stripling model of Inquiry that the LOC uses with Primary Sources. I was glad that I got to experience a lesson of this type lesson from a student's view point. I was able to better understand how student's learning is NOT a linear process between the different parts of the model. I was also able to think about how this model was able to have me personalize my learning in the use of the materials available to respond to the focus of the inquiry lesson. From this lesson I was able to build my understandings of how to frame personalized learning for students. This is how I view this model being used for Personalized Learning based on my experience as a student.
Stripling Model of Inquiry
|
- Lesson Focus (Setting the Stage) is established by the teacher through the selection of entry materials to be analyzed and discussed to begin to understand the topic. The entry level analysis floats between the Reflect, Express, Construct stages as students individually analyze Primary Sources, Reflect on the identified details and discuss Connections made between the various Primary Resources available. Through this preliminary Investigation, I was able to start Constructing meaning of the lesson focus. Small group and whole class discussion is crucial for this process so perspectives from others can be considered as well to build and deepen the consideration of other's perspectives and the ability to "Think Like a Historian" as mentioned in Day 3. Through the discussion and my own analyzing and investigating the preliminary Wondering questions began to develop. This is where, I believe, I found where the remaining part of the lesson path for the student can branch. Path 1-teacher directed, Path 2-teacher facilitated w/student input, Path 3-student directed w/teacher facilitation as needed. This is where I found personalized learning in this model as describe in Personalized Learning by Allison Zmuda. I also appreciated the various organizers that have been provided to us as they allowed me to structure my notes and efficiently use the "Think Like a Historian" process of identifying the Source, author, purpose, perspectives of differing views of the time, and to also consider the time and place of the Primary Source.
- Construct/Investigate/Wonder: An Essential Question is the guiding focus for the student's Inquiry. Without this piece the personalized learning experience can stray to the irrelevant. The question can be created by the teacher summarizing discussions during the preliminary Investigating & Wonder parts of the model. however having the student create their own question following the investigate and wonder parts of the model, empowers the student to develop a learning path that deepens their understanding of the content, own their learning and decide on the relevance of the information available. This is the mortar that will guide and hold the student's focus for the entire duration of the project. Without it the project can and will ramble and be nebulous.
- Investigation/Reflect/Express/Connect: After I developed my Essential Question from my Wonders I began to investigate the resources I was wanting to use which included searching recommended sites myself including additional information from secondary resources that would show my understandings of the topic and answer my question.
- Connect/Construct: Student Ownership came in the connect and construct stages as I compiled all my information and organized my information to a format and display of my choosing. As a student in this lesson, creating the final product and choosing how I wanted to display the information to my audience really had me considering the audience that was going to be listening and viewing MY information. This helped me revise, seek feedback, revise some more until I was satisfied with how I planned to deliver my information to my audience.
- From being a student through this process, I now understand some of the challenges that personalized learning can be encountered by the student and the teacher:
- Clarity of Expectations and Goals: I found that asking clarifying questions is a great safety net for personalized learning(something students really need to be taught and encouraged to use. I am going to change the way I ask if anyone has questions to "Does anyone need me to clarify anything they are puzzled about regarding their learning?") Clearly state the Lesson Focus with vocabulary, objectives, monitoring of goals and work progress, time lines and have these points available to all learners at all times so that students feel they're empowered to monitor themselves.
- Reflection-needed by the student (although at first I thought this step was very ridiculous and didn't take it serious the first day) this time was so valuable in helping me think about what I had accomplished, what I still needed to do, and just take time to think overall about what learning I was constructing and how it was connecting to the overall focus for the content I was learning. Reflection also helped me begin the developing my project presentation and questions for feedback.
- Feedback-this is SOOOO critical and where I also discovered that confusion is where real learning begins and clarity is where understandings and reasoning begin to be revealed. During this time, I have also found is where we don't let students be confused and facilitate and guide their way through it--we don't have time (this week was a crunch and as an adult. It is up to the learner to determine when and what to share). There were times, that the facilitators of the institute wanted talk, check in with me and I literally had to say---I'm still puzzling about how I want to synthesize my ideas and information so that it is comprehensible to someone else. Isolation for thinking shouldn't be a problem and at times quietness although can be uncomfortable is a great way to create that clarity. The facilitators assisted me by reminding me of some provided checklists, graphic organizers etc. It actually it took me 2 days to where I finally felt I was ready for a check-in session with the facilitators. On day 3 I was ready for a check-in session and to seek feedback. This is where I experienced the good, the bad, and the ugly. I got feedback on my project from one of the facilitators that was a springboard for research that I could include in my project that I considered very helpful as well as several questions that included What was my project about, How will my audience be able to use my information in my project, and Why(good and constructive that helped provide the clarity I needed in the production of my project). I sought feedback from a class participant-they liked my project (the ugly-it didn't help me at all). I sought out perspectives from librarians and classroom teachers. I appreciated all the honest feedback that I got even if it was I don't understand what you are doing. I learned two important things about feedback: 1) the project creator has to ask specific questions they want for feedback responses{students need to be taught this and will be part of my instructional process this year] and 2) feedback MUST be sought out from a variety of viewpoints so that the creator can understand how their information is perceived by different people related to the class learning and from outside of the class who don't know what the content being learned. This is where my most valuable feedback came from. If somebody unknowing of the content can understand my project then I have done a successful job as a learner. I sought feedback from about 10 people during the last 3 days of the creation of my project, some with work experience as a librarian, classroom teacher and a couple of people that only did research and weren't part of our institute, just visiting. I learned that student feedback being contained within 4 walls doesn't let them determine the type of feedback they need for their project. I also have realized that students need to create their own questions to personalize the feedback so that it is meaningful to them. Having students say the like the project is NOT a benefit to the project creator. Saying things like your project is interesting to me. Have you considered... with a why when it comes to possible revisions is a necessary step students need to learn and be taught for personalized learning to take place. My project would have never developed they way it did if the facilitators just looked at it without me and with good questions and comments. Even the feedback about I like helped me know to ask specific questions instead of asking what do you think?
- Sharing is huge. That is where me as the student got the nervousness of “is my project good enough, will people understand and the thrill of being able to show my learning and understanding of the topic.” Thank heavens for the Lesson Focus and my Essential Question to keep everything together, organized, and on track for completion. Sharing is where I got to feel good about being confused, struggling with be frustrated in my research and getting the vision out of my head into a comprehensible format for an audience and FAILING in research, design, and at times clarity. I felt confident and proud to answer questions by people who didn't know anything about my struggles or my project because I was an expert on my project and my purpose. I owned all that information in the format I presented it. I was an accomplished learner that could be a teacher and that is what I truly believe is Personalized Learning.
Day 3
I have included links to documents and videos as additional resources. Today is focused on perspectives and historical thinking. We learned about an instructional strategy called Circle of Viewpoints. This strategy has students think about different intended audiences from the time. From an article we used about immigration in 1904 it was amazing to see the amount of viewpoints and audience types would/could have been interested in this information from this resource. The best part of considering the viewpoints is the role play to build students synthesis of the purpose of the artifact and how the artifact impacts the audience members perspective and responses. This activity really moves students thinking up Bloom's Taxonomy to the highest level as well as depth of knowledge as students have to orally present a response as an identified audience member to the class. One I won't forget is reviewing a song. The song was "Don't Bite the Hand That's Feeding You" First we just looked at the sheet music the song, analyzed it and discussed its purpose and considered the different viewpoint audiences. Then listened to actual recording of the song. It was amazing how the song modified our viewpoints about the song. Check out the links for your viewpoints about this resource. Please comment your viewpoints about each of these resources. I would be interested to see what your viewpoints.
Our final activity for the day was Thinking Like an Historian. Here is a video link for an introduction. This instructional strategy has students conduct research using multiple resources on a topic then using specific steps critically analyze the artifacts by identifying the artifacts source, contextual meaning, and close reading strategies to decide credibility, purpose, viewpoints/perspectives, key facts, details from the artifacts and the corroborating the information across multiple texts to synthesize information to form both sources to see where the documents agree and disagree. This was a very interesting process that allows students to not rely on what they know, but what they are understanding from the information that is being gathered and analyzed regarding the period in time from the artifacts.
Tomorrow I will be reflecting on an Inquiry Model and my project I have been developing during this week so stay tuned....
Our final activity for the day was Thinking Like an Historian. Here is a video link for an introduction. This instructional strategy has students conduct research using multiple resources on a topic then using specific steps critically analyze the artifacts by identifying the artifacts source, contextual meaning, and close reading strategies to decide credibility, purpose, viewpoints/perspectives, key facts, details from the artifacts and the corroborating the information across multiple texts to synthesize information to form both sources to see where the documents agree and disagree. This was a very interesting process that allows students to not rely on what they know, but what they are understanding from the information that is being gathered and analyzed regarding the period in time from the artifacts.
Tomorrow I will be reflecting on an Inquiry Model and my project I have been developing during this week so stay tuned....
Day 2
Today focused on using Primary Source Maps and the instructional strategy of Making Thinking Visual. Our facilitators, Anne and Thomas, guided us through a Jigsaw activity using a Primary Source Map. There were several new strategies modeled in this activity that I really liked such as:
- Think, Puzzle, Explore-a spin on the KWL. The difference being students shouldn't be limited by their prior knowledge because the work THINK allows students to predict or hypothesize a response. I like the word PUZZLE as a way to help the students get to creating questions about the Primary Source they are analyzing. Explore is a great friendly term for investigating. The new phrasing for this type of thinking process builds a Growth Mindset
- A noting strategy for students is to use sticky note flags with their observations and place it on the object then explain to the others in their group what their notes are on the map. I liked this strategy instead of students using a separate piece of paper so that the information is in all one place for others to see.
Great way to drive a Jigsaw discussion with a map, is make a map large and cut it up into sections. Each student individually uses sticky flags to note what they observe then hypothesize a purpose for the map based on their observations for their piece. The group then gathers and places their map section upside down till it time for them to share with their group members then places their pieces upside down till everyone has shared. Then the group assembles the map sections to create the whole. The group then discusses the whole and can use this sentence frame to guide the changes in their thinking
- I use to think __(old hypothesis) Now I think __(new hypothesis) because __ (new evidence)
This sentence frame, does help move students' thinking to higher Bloom's Taxonomy to synthesis and evaluation. The final step is the group creates a Heading/Title for the map and shares. The creation of the Heading/Title allows students to creatively state the map's purpose-it also provides a monitoring point for the teacher.
The day closed with a visit to the Main Reading Room in the Thomas Jefferson Library. This was icing on the cake. the Main Reading Room is an octagon with Alcoves that books are shelved for use by the public that have a Readers Card-which is free to get and valid for 2 years. We also got to visit the room with the card catalogs and the books for cataloging. It was soooo cool to actually page through different cards. They even have hand written catalog cards. Will be posting picture albums soon.
Day 1
was interesting and engaging as all of us learned more about the Library of Congress website and how to navigate the numerous links. I am going to have to practice to get really familiar with the different pages and what the purpose for the pages are to be able to quickly navigate the website and assist others in the website's use.In the afternoon, we got into a really good discussion about Primary and Secondary Sources as small collaborative groups examined several artifacts and articles from a time in history from the Library of Congress. The discussion was very engaging to learn about the different perspectives attendees had why a resource was either a Primary or Secondary source. We also spent time reflecting on the Library of Congress' definition of a Primary and Secondary source:
Primary sources are the raw materials of history — original documents and objects which were created at the time under study. They are different from secondary sources, accounts or interpretations of events created by someone without firsthand experience.
I am still pondering this definition to deepen my understandings of Primary and Secondary Sources. Any comments about the quoted definition?


Overall I like the secondary source definition... but here's my question, what if someone is a direct witness to the event, not the one experiencing it, but "at the right place, at the right time"--does that make your observations primary or secondary source. At some level you are analyzing the experience, but it is also your experience.
ReplyDeleteI'm thinking of reporters and how they are at the razor's edge of an incident. Are they part of that? In a way, yes, but not really. They are still on the outside looking in, the witness to history.
Just curious.
Hi Wendy,
DeleteThanks for your questions and following my blog. In regards to your question about reporters; we had some good discussion about newspapers and reporting of eye witness accounts. From what I have been able to discern from the discussions and examples we have used in model lessons and guides is that it comes down to how the article is written as a true account of facts or a retell of information such as a reporting of an eye witness. What I have come to understand Primary VS secondary reports is the viewpoint the article is written in First Person is Primary; Second or Third Person is Secondary.
sorry forgot to sign in.... it's me
ReplyDeleteComment #2.... when you mentioned not focusing on background knowledge, made me think about what we focus on when activating BK. Explain that more to me.
ReplyDeleteLove the whole process!!
Hi Wendy,
DeleteThink about he word think (I know redundant)? When I was asked to think about what I saw or was hearing, I was more open to share my ideas. When I was asked what i knew about what I saw or heard and didn't have anything I knew, I was less likely to share questions or ideas. Using the word THINK eliminated the responsibility of knowing and brought the "freedom" of experimenting with relevant ideas and possibilities so that I build my background knowledge as the discussion continues. Its a game changer!
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
ReplyDeleteWow.... Day 3 ideas! I love the video and how the kids are using their primary source documents to discuss an essential question. Now, where would personalized learning happen? AFTER this? During? Is this more like a data swim time.... immersed in the ideas, then kids move from this into their own questions related to this?
ReplyDeleteLove the PERSPECTIVE piece again!! It's everywhere!
The song... OMG... offensive? Timely? Wow... we haven't moved far in our thinking about immigrants. Thing is in 1912, that is when my Irish immigrant grandparents came to this country. Do immigrants need time to come to an understanding or assimilation into their new country (sounds like the Borg, from Star Trek doesn't it?)
Do prejudices every go away? I would LOVE to hear what you all talked about in your group!! Love it!
Hi Wendy,
ReplyDeleteDuring day 4 I elaborated on the process to show where personalized learning continues. I agree with your think about the data swim, to begin the personalized learning journey the teacher begins with multiple resources to be reviewed and using an inquiry model begin building students focus. After the initial "data swim" students use the inquiry model creates a Wonder question to guide the use of additional resources and other strategies used in class to determine credibility and relevancy of information to answer their question and to include in a final project. The teacher has set the focus, the students personalize their learning using known processes following expectations, goals, feedback, and timelines.
Your reaction to the song was the same as mine. However, it was interesting how the song seemed to make the words somewhat OK and the patriotic nature of the melody made it seem even more appropriate. Who would have thought that music could be considered the first social media device....
I never thought of music or a song as being social media device... BUT IT SO IS!!! Makes me wonder about other lyrics. I like that you think the data swim still has a place.
DeleteOkay I am only going to look at each day separately and then respond. Okay, Day 4. I liked what you said about having a "focus". Is that the same as an essential question (overall theme, such as perspective--rather than the "question" you want the kids to answer). Then the kids do the data swim, with the teacher providing ONLY the initial source material to get them thinking from different points of view. THEN the kids personalize it with their own question and continue their "research" to answer their question that came from the intial "swim".
ReplyDeleteIs that it, in a nutshell? Or is there more. I understand giving them the organizers and rubrics, the standards, the big picture. My question is, when the kids choose their own question to answer-- didn't you mention before (or was it in the PL or Innovator's book) that what you answer or create has to make the world a better place. Or is that thinking only with innovator projects?
Could kids make themselves "better" by investigating their own thinking with a complex issue, like equality or inequality of civil rights?
I don't see kids solving that issue or problem in the world, but what if they explore such a big theme of perspective or perception, of seeing through someone else's eyes or the investigation of that issue throughout various time periods. IE how human rights or freedoms were perceived or acted upon in Lincoln's time or in MLK's time or today around the world? What if it shifts to women's rights or children's rights? It's still in the same arena?
If that is all so, then wouldn't the focus need to be so broad, initially to get the kids asking questions, but the kids investigation would narrow the focus to look at the theme with laser focus from a variety of perspectives???
Or am I way off?
My other question is about kids like Kyle who don't yet (and maybe many others who don't have his limitations and issues) who struggle to synthesize information from multiple sources before they can look again to be prompted to a "what do you wonder now", place? Is that part of the clarifying part of this process.
Almost a what are these several sources talking about (good ideas of for discussions~!!), then comes the "so what, now what," place.
Again, is that on the right track or completely off??
I love the "Thought Portal" idea!!! I especially like the idea that you would have several and kids could choose one to pursue. Made me IMMEDIATELY start thinking about that idea with "thought portals" regarding perspective. Books about kids experiences with different time periods, diaries, historical fiction, non-fiction artifacts-- each dealing with perception or perspective, but different cultures or experiences.... how do kids see things? Authors? Illustrators? Comic book authors? Playwrights? Singers??
ReplyDeleteStill really like the KWL adaptation of Think, Puzzle, Wonder. So much more accessible. I also like the jot notes bookmarks because one of the things I always do as a reader is jot notes-- which is what we always did in our notebooks (be that online or paper), but again reminds me of that power.
Personalized question again..... would they have to have a "project" or is the support of collecting and sharing the project? What if the classroom teacher wasn't "on board" with supporting the work, how could we support kids to do this work and encourage this thinking in the classroom environment?
The gallery walk, we'll have to talk more. I love when kids share and I love when they get to see other's ideas because this would only be one project or exploration.... Still loving the TED talk idea....